The case of Scotland’s lacking worldwide technique and Erasmus alternative — science weblog

The federal government, led by the Scottish Nationalist Occasion, mentioned it might develop a new technique for worldwide schooling to “promote Scotland’s schooling supply globally, improve the variety of worldwide college students, and keep our hyperlinks with the EU”, within the 2021/22 parliamentary 12 months.

It mentioned a reciprocal Scottish Schooling Change Programme – just like the Taith program in Wales – would “assist the worldwide mobility of workers and learners”. Leaders additionally mentioned the devolved parliament would “work to re‑safe Scotland’s entry to the Erasmus + Programme”.

It’s not clear why the 2 initiatives have been delayed – they had been already delayed earlier than Nicola Sturgeon give up as first minister in February. However, after the Scottish authorities reversed a call to allocate £46m to schools and universities “with out warning” on Might 3, there’s stress on the federal government – and its new chief Humza Yousaf – to launch a plan on the way it plans to fund greater schooling in Scotland.

Talking on Good Morning Scotland on Might 3, director of Universities Scotland, Alastair Sim, mentioned the organisation was “very disillusioned and clearly fairly puzzled at this fairly sudden abstraction of the useful resource”.

“We had been trying ahead to having the ability to spend money on a method that might meet college students’ wants. We’re seeing college students want much more assist after the pandemic… We’re investing a lot cash in making an attempt to fulfill elevated welfare and instructing wants,” he mentioned.

The funding may even have helped Scottish establishments of their analysis competitiveness, which he mentioned has been eroded as “analysis funding [has been] minimize from Scottish authorities by 36% since 2014/15”.

“The Scottish authorities, they don’t actually say it out loud, however I feel they are surely betting every thing on development in worldwide college students and that’s reaching some extent of monumental geopolitical threat,” he mentioned.

“Scottish authorities is basically forcing us to guess every thing on one quantity on the roulette wheel”

A spokesperson from Universities Scotland informed The PIE that the organisation is trying ahead to the upcoming publication of the Scottish authorities’s Worldwide Schooling Technique, which it hopes “will recognise the numerous advantages, socially and economically, that worldwide schooling contributes to Scotland”.

“To cross-subsidise the underfunding of Scottish college students and analysis, we now have more cash coming in from worldwide college students than we do from instructing Scottish domicile college students. That builds monumental dangers that if there’s one other conflict, difficulties in relations with China, if UK authorities restricts immigration coverage, this might collapse,” Sim mentioned.

“By selecting to underfund the core instructing of Scottish college students and selecting to underfund the core analysis infrastructure, Scottish authorities is basically forcing us to guess every thing on one quantity on the roulette wheel, and that’s received big dangers.”

HESA statistics from 2021/22 present that of the £1.59bn Scottish greater schooling generated in tuition charges, £1.03bn got here from non-EU college students. In 2020/21, non-EU college students contributed £867m in tuition charges.

Sim appealed to authorities to prioritise funding in additional and better schooling in the subsequent Scottish finances if the federal government is severe about Scotland “being a excessive expertise and an innovation led economic system”.

The federal government has mentioned it’s going through essentially the most difficult monetary surroundings since devolution and really tough selections throughout portfolios must be made.

Minister for Greater and Additional Schooling since 2023, Graeme Dey – who welcomed Germany’s Parliamentary State Secretary to the Federal Minister for Schooling and Analysis Jens Brandenburg to Scotland in Might – was requested just lately requested in Scottish Parliament about instructional exchanges with Europe.

Dey highlighted that because of Brexit, Scottish universities have seen a 64% discount in numbers of European college students, which has “undoubtedly impacted on our universities”.

“The Scottish authorities welcomes the contribution that European and different worldwide college students make to our greater schooling sector, in addition to to our society, our tradition and our economic system. They add variety,” he mentioned on April 27.

“Any proposals from the UK authorities so as to add extra restrictive visa necessities for European and different worldwide college students can be deeply damaging to our world-class college sector.”

Following the UK’s resolution to go away the European Union, the Scottish authorities mentioned in December 2020 it had “sought repeated assurance that the UK authorities will prioritise continued affiliation” to the Erasmus program.

“The lack of Erasmus is big blow. That is merely unacceptable and we’re different choices,” the then Scottish universities minister Richard Lochhead mentioned on the time.

In an announcement to The PIE, Universities Scotland added that since Brexit ended entry to Erasmus+, the Welsh authorities has delivered its two-way mobility Taith scheme, to the worth of £65 million over 4 years, which is “thriving”.

“Universities will proceed to supply college students the chance to review overseas however this might be made considerably simpler with a Scottish scheme,” the organisation mentioned.

In February of this 12 months, Jamie Hepburn – who’s now minister for Independence within the Scottish Nationwide Occasion authorities – reiterated that the Scottish authorities stays dedicated to Erasmus+ and is creating a Scottish Schooling Change Programme “to assist individuals from throughout Scotland’s schooling system” within the interin.


Ministers had been beforehand accused of “shelving plans” for this system in 2022, after admitting there was no timetable for consulting on it.

“It is a program for presidency dedication and can assist keep Scotland’s place as an outward trying, internationally related vacation spot for work and examine,” Hepburn mentioned in February.

“We’re partaking with stakeholders from throughout the schooling spectrum, together with greater and additional schooling, colleges (together with early years and care), vocational schooling and coaching, youth work, grownup schooling and sports activities. We’re listening to the sectors and the wants of their learners and workers as a way to guarantee we create a program match for Scotland.”

It is a assertion the Scottish authorities repeated when requested by The PIE when the technique and knowledge on SEEP might be launched.

“In follow, we now have worldwide charges subsidising Scottish college students – that carries lots of geopolitical threat”

Universities Scotland famous that there’s a “greater concern across the unsustainable funding mannequin that Scottish universities at the moment function underneath”.

“In follow, we now have worldwide charges subsidising Scottish college students. That carries lots of geopolitical threat and one we want to see the Scottish authorities treatment by funding the sector sustainably,” the spokesperson concluded.

Supply hyperlink